Feb. 1st, 2014

sheenaghpugh: (Default)
If there's one generalisation about genre writers that really annoys me, it's the one that says "people who write historical fiction are escapists, not facing up to problems in the contemporary world". In fact they are frequently addressing the contemporary a lot more adroitly than those who actually set their novels there and have less distance from their material. Hilary Mantel's "A Place of Greater Safety" was published in 1992, quite a while before a post-9/11 world started getting twitchy about whether the ordinary forms of law were appropriate for fighting "terrorism". Here's Danton and Robespierre discussing the matter:

Danton: How do you tell a conspirator?
Robespierre: Put them on trial.
Danton: What if you know they’re conspirators, but you haven’t enough evidence to convict them? What if you as a patriot just know?
Robespierre: You ought to be able to make it stand up in court.
Danton: Suppose you can’t? You might not be able to use your strongest evidence. It might be state secrets.
Robespierre: You’d have to let them go, in that case. But it would be unfortunate.
Danton: It would, wouldn’t it? If the Austrians were at the gates? And you were delivering the city over to them out of respect for the judicial process?
Robespierre: Well, I suppose you’d…you’d have to alter the standard of proof in court. Or widen the definition of conspiracy.
Danton: You would, would you?
Robespierre: Would that be an example of a lesser evil averting a greater one? I am not usually taken in by this simple, very comforting very infantile notion—but I know that a successful conspiracy against the French people could lead to genocide.
Danton: Perverting justice is a very great evil in itself. It leaves no hope of amendment.
Robespierre: Look, Danton, I don’t know, I’m not a theorist.

Profile

sheenaghpugh: (Default)
sheenaghpugh

September 2025

S M T W T F S
  123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930    

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 17th, 2025 01:58 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios